The consumer’s issue:
In February 2022, a consumer purchased a seven-year-old ’15-plate diesel saloon for £17,000. Around three years later, in January 2025, they took their car to a franchise dealership for its 100,000-mile service and MOT. However, less than two weeks after leaving the workshop, the vehicle suffered a breakdown, and a warning came up on the dashboard explaining that the oil needed to be topped up.
The car was recovered, and a subsequent investigation into the breakdown revealed a turbo failure and oil contamination in the intercooler, but the consumer deemed the lack of oil to be the root cause. Nevertheless, the vehicle owner needed the car, and proceeded to pay £2,500 for the repairs ‘under protest’, and demanded a full refund for this cost as a resolution to their complaint. The business however, never responded to the consumer following a request for a written response in relation to the issue.
The case outcome:
The Motor Ombudsman adjudicator reviewed the evidence supplied by both parties and noted that, under the obligations of the Service and Repair Code, businesses are required to ensure that work completed on consumer vehicles are done with reasonable skill and care.
Based on what had happened, the adjudicator stated that timing in relation to when the breakdown happened was not in itself evidence of a breach of the Code of practice or down to the standard of work undertaken. In addition, job cards from the routine service did not highlight any faults or concerns that the business ought to have reasonably identified. Similarly, the consumer had not provided any independent technical evidence to support their position that the business was liable for covering the cost of repairs.
Conclusion:
As there was no causal link between the breakdown experienced and the work completed by the business, the adjudicator did not uphold this element of the complaint in the consumer’s favour. However, they did confirm that, because the business did not respond, this in itself was a breach. Therefore, the complaint was partially upheld on this aspect of the dispute. With no request for an ombudsman’s final decision, the case was closed.
Key learning point:
Businesses are required to complete work with reasonable skill and care. This entails adhering to industry standards and vehicle manufacturer guidelines.
Vehicles develop faults due to a wide range of reasons. It is not sufficient to state that simply because a business completed a repair or service on a vehicle, that any issue or specific component thereafter is related to their workmanship.

